The
territorial defeat of Daesh was simply the first of a long series of phases
needed to destroy the terrorist organization and its ideology completely. This
may be the first time a US-led campaign has knocked down buildings and
destroyed cities and claimed victory over a terrorist insurgency.
But Sunni
insurgencies are not defeated by punishing Sunni population centers and
destroying cities in bombing campaigns. Insurgencies are grown when a sectarian
government indiscriminately targets and disappears Sunni males in the tens of
thousands.
The children
of non-affiliated Sunni males killed or imprisoned while awaiting execution for
being Daesh collaborators will grow up to seek revenge. They do not have to
believe in a terrorist ideology to use the group as a vehicle for revenge.
The way
Sunni areas of Iraq were destroyed in the anti-Daesh campaign simply reset the
conditions that led to the terror group to begin with. The Iraqi government and
the militias that destroyed Sunni towns, with US air power in support, took
territory away by destroying city blocks and infrastructure. But Daesh can now
conduct an attack anywhere in Iraq.
Reconstruction
is lagging in the destroyed Sunni areas of Iraq by design. Sunnis are not being
recruited into the ranks of a uniformed force to hold territory and secure the
population in areas previously controlled by Daesh. The thinking in Baghdad and
in prominent think tank sectors of Washington — both are wrong — is that Sunni
and Kurdish areas are best when governed by Shiite forces; after all, it’s the
Sunnis and the Kurds that are causing problems. This argument does not work and
fails with the Shiite youth protest movement joining the ranks of the
disenfranchised and Iran’s militias running rampant across Iraq.
In the case
of Iraq, the forces operating in these disenfranchised areas are not Iraqis
that happen to be Shiite and wear the uniform of the Iraqi Army or the Iraqi
Police — they are the militias, more loyal to Tehran than Iraq.
The
Iran-backed militias see every military-aged Sunni male as a future Daesh
fighter or a former or future Daesh collaborator. They do not know these Sunni
areas, they do not know the tribes, they are not trusted, and they treat Sunnis
as cells that are ready to be infected with the Daesh disease. The distrust
between Iraqis from all sects and these Iran-backed militias is currently the
highest it has ever been, and Daesh is watching.
If we could go back to 2013-14, right before Daesh rolled
into Mosul, we would see the same conditions present today: An oppressive
sectarian government disinterested in the disenfranchised Sunnis of Anbar,
Salah ad Din, Diyala and Nineveh provinces; a government that is
unanswerable to the disappearance of tens of thousands of Sunnis at the hands
of security forces stretching from Jurf Al-Nasr to Ramadi and Tikrit.
The coalition bombing campaign in Iraq and the clearing
operations in Ramadi and Mosul destroyed whole sectors of these heavily
populated cities. The operations killed tens of thousands and forced 2 million
Iraqis to leave these cities and join the internally displaced refugee
population.
At no time during the campaign were Sunni military-aged males
empowered by Baghdad or the US to take on this Sunni terrorist threat.The
lessons of the 2007 Surge, when the US empowered Sunnis to take back their
neighborhoods from Al-Qaeda and Iran-backed militias, were shelved. Instead,
theUS effectively acted as theair force for Qassem Soleimani’s
militias.
US Central Command assesses Daesh as being as strong now as
it was right before it occupied Mosul with 2,000 fighters. US officials believe
there are thousands of Daesh fightersoperating in the ungoverned spaces
along the Iraq-Syria border. The caliphate is alive and well, as it now
operates along the lines of the Al-Qaeda model in Iraq and Syria, while also
holding and gaining territory in the ungoverned spaces of the Sahel region of
Africa.
But who is actually paying attention? The US is more focused
on protecting its forces from Iran-backed militias than going after Daesh. The
militias themselves aren’t focused on Daesh — they are focused on killing and
disappearing Shiite youths in the protest movement, on defending their
headquarters in Shiite areas from these protesters, and on moving arms and
forces into Syria. Last but not least, they are also attacking the US missions
in Iraq and Syria and attempting to force the US out of Iraq.
Daesh is taking advantage of the coronavirus disease, the
distrust of militias, protests, and a security situation where the US and its
supposed partners have ceded territory in Sunni areas and along the Syrian
border to Iran-backed militias. The Iraqi government and the US continue to
take their eyes off the ball.
The US will carry on developing intelligence to target Daesh
cells and key leaders, but what is growing now in the unprotected Sunni areas
of Iraq and Syria is a pool of young recruits left without answers or a say in
a country that has moved on. They want justice and they want revenge against
Baghdad, Tehran and the US.
To ensure the enduring defeat of Daesh, the US must put
pressure on Baghdad to bring Sunnis into the uniformed military to operate in
areas where the terror group survives, due to the local population’s distrust
of the militias. The US must pressure Prime Minister Mustafa Al-Kadhimi to
disarm and force the Iran-backed militias out of the security apparatus, as
well as reform the electoral law and hold free and fair elections. The US must
also pressure Baghdad to allocate and expedite funds toward reconstruction in
destroyed Sunni areas. These recommendations arethe only way to keep
Daesh from learning from its lessons and applying them to wreak havocat a
time of its choosing. The current situation is making this a likely
scenario— a very dangerous yet avoidable one.